The 10 Best Small Towns In New York For 2024

You’ve seen these lists before. Best places to live in New York. Best sururbs in New York. Best counties in New York.

Etc., etc., etc.

But they all focus on major cities and towns in the Empire State, and no one pays attention to the little guy.

Well, that’s all about to change as we put together a list of the superb small towns in New York based on numbers–not opinions or hearsay.

We’ll dive right into our methodology in the next section, but first, we thought you might want to know which places in New York ranked the best based on Saturday Night Science.

---

Table Of Contents: Top Ten | Methodology | Summary | Table

---

The 15 Best Small Towns To Live In New York For 2024

1. Saddle Rock
2. Pittsford
3. East Williston
4. Russell Gardens
5. Brightwaters
6. Roslyn Estates
7. Skaneateles
8. Great Neck Estates
9. Flower Hill
10. Plandome
11. Claverack-Red Mills
12. Glenwood Landing
13. Sparkill
14. Hartsdale
15. Westvale

What’s the best small town in New York? Saddle Rock is the best small town in New York based on the most recent Census data. If you live in one of these small towns like Saddle Rock, chances are, you’re not surprised. After all, you know how great you have it.

But for the rest of you–keep reading, and we’ll get to just why these small towns made our list.

For more reading on the Empire State check out:

• Best Places To Live In New York
• Cheapest Places To Live In New York
• Most Dangerous Places In New York

The 15 Best Small Towns In New York For 2024

1. Saddle Rock

Overall SnackAbility

/10

Population: 1,207
Median Income: $192,875 (29th Best)
Median Home Value: $1,945,964 (15th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 0.6%

2. Pittsford

Overall SnackAbility

7
/10

Population: 1,644
Median Income: $116,250 (105th Best)
Median Home Value: $433,305 (148th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 1.9%

3. East Williston

Source: Public domain

Overall SnackAbility

5
/10

Population: 2,630
Median Income: $225,833 (24th Best)
Median Home Value: $1,172,966 (47th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 1.6%

4. Russell Gardens

Overall SnackAbility

7
/10

Population: 1,100
Median Income: $165,313 (49th Best)
Median Home Value: $1,682,442 (27th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 2.4%

5. Brightwaters

Overall SnackAbility

7
/10

Population: 3,181
Median Income: $187,581 (33rd Best)
Median Home Value: $725,410 (83rd Best)
Unemployment Rate: 3.1%

6. Roslyn Estates

Overall SnackAbility

5
/10

Population: 1,350
Median Income: $250,001 (8th Best)
Median Home Value: $1,943,962 (16th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 2.2%

7. Skaneateles

Source: Wikipedia User The original uploader was Phmalo at English Wikipedia | CC BY-SA 2.5

Overall SnackAbility

6
/10

Population: 2,539
Median Income: $117,976 (101st Best)
Median Home Value: $662,634 (92nd Best)
Unemployment Rate: 2.4%

8. Great Neck Estates

Overall SnackAbility

7
/10

Population: 2,936
Median Income: $175,515 (41st Best)
Median Home Value: $1,900,729 (21st Best)
Unemployment Rate: 1.4%

9. Flower Hill

Overall SnackAbility

6
/10

Population: 4,787
Median Income: $250,001 (8th Best)
Median Home Value: $2,272,864 (8th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 3.2%

10. Plandome

Overall SnackAbility

4
/10

Population: 1,365
Median Income: $250,001 (8th Best)
Median Home Value: $2,356,033 (6th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 2.4%

11. Claverack-Red Mills

Overall SnackAbility

/10

Population: 1,042
Median Income: $147,500 (61st Best)
Median Home Value: $276,951 (227th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 0.0%

12. Glenwood Landing

Overall SnackAbility

6
/10

Population: 3,694
Median Income: $121,612 (95th Best)
Median Home Value: $818,413 (73rd Best)
Unemployment Rate: 3.2%

13. Sparkill

Overall SnackAbility

5
/10

Population: 1,125
Median Income: $178,750 (39th Best)
Median Home Value: $650,644 (96th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 2.3%

14. Hartsdale

Overall SnackAbility

7
/10

Population: 3,082
Median Income: $157,891 (53rd Best)
Median Home Value: $648,076 (97th Best)
Unemployment Rate: 1.6%

15. Westvale

Overall SnackAbility

7
/10

Population: 4,933
Median Income: $103,646 (133rd Best)
Median Home Value: $212,396 (292nd Best)
Unemployment Rate: 1.4%

Next 10 Cities

Methodology: How We Determined The Coolest Towns In New York

We threw a lot of criteria at this report to get the best, most complete results of the best small towns in New York possible.

Using the most recent data from the Census’s 2018-2022 American Community Survey, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, and Saturday Night Science, this is the criteria we used:

• Population Density (Higher is better)
• Lowest Unemployment Rates
• Housing costs (Higher is better. More demand.)
• Adjusted Median Income (Higher is better)
• Highly Educated Adults (Higher is better)
• Insurance Rates (Higher is better)
• Commute Times (Lower is better)

We looked at places with populations lower than 5,000 people and greater than 1,000, of which there were many – 453 to be exact.

We then ranked each place in each category with scores from 1 to 453, averaged them out, and the lowest scores went to our Best Small Towns in New York. Top of that list — Saddle Rock.

This is our tenth time ranking the best small places to live in New York.

Summary: Science Can Tackle Any Issue, Even Small Ones

We said it once, and we’ll say it again — this list: it’s just science. We did the research, crunched the numbers, and it turns out these 15 small towns in New York are the best in which to live.

And who can argue with that?

The best small towns in New York are Saddle Rock, Pittsford, East Williston, Russell Gardens, Brightwaters, Roslyn Estates, Skaneateles, Great Neck Estates, Flower Hill, and Plandome.

If you’re curious, here are the worst small towns in New York:

1. Whitehall
2. Yorkshire
3. Whitney Point

For more New York reading, check out:

• Best Places To Raise A Family In New York
• Safest Places In New York According To Science
• Worst Places To Live In New York State

Best Small Towns In New York